Cherries: Referee may have set 'dangerous' precedent says Howe

BOSS Eddie Howe believes referee Carl Boyeson may have set a “dangerous” precedent for himself after changing his mind over a penalty decision during Cherries’ 2-2 draw at Bury yesterday.

The experienced official awarded Cherries a second-half spot kick for handball against Shakers defender Matt Doherty and then reversed his decision after consulting his assistant.

Boyeson, who appeared well placed to view the incident, took several seconds to point to the spot, only to signal for a corner after speaking with the linesman who was on the opposite side of the pitch.

And while opinion was divided as to whether or not Boyeson had made the correct decision, Howe fears the Hull-based official could face ramifications when taking charge of future matches.

Howe, who spoke to Boyeson as the teams left the pitch at the final whistle, told the Daily Echo: “He said he thought it was a penalty and, as soon as he had made the decision, he thought it was a bad one.

“I know there was an arm raised and, whether it hit his arm or not, it didn’t take away from the fact that the referee gave a penalty and then decided to change his mind. Whether it was or wasn’t, he shouldn’t have given it in the first place if he wasn’t certain.

“That type of scenario is just going to encourage players to protest and you will have players in the faces of referees and linesmen. I wouldn’t want to see a penalty given if it wasn’t but, once you give the decision, you have got to stick with it.

“It was just the fact that he changed his mind because that was a dangerous thing to do. If you are an official and players get wind of it, you will just have melee upon melee after decisions you feel are contentious.”

The incident, which came after Doherty had climbed at the far post to defend a Simon Francis cross, took place when Bury were leading 1-0 thanks to Troy Hewitt’s stunning 14th-minute opener.

However, after Lewis Grabban had struck to restore parity and David Worrall had netted to restore the Shakers’ advantage, Brett Pitman came off the bench to grab a dramatic injury-time equaliser.

Speaking about the penalty decision, Bury manager Kevin Blackwell said: “I have got to give praise to the referee. You see referees who are so arrogant that they feel that if they change their mind, it is a flaw or a weakness.

“He took his time, he spoke to his linesman and they both said he had headed it out. There was an arm up but it was for balance. He made the correct decision.”

Cherries midfielder Harry Arter picked up his fifth booking of the season and an automatic one-match suspension for protesting the decision. He will sit out the FA Cup second round clash at Carlisle.

Comments (8)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:15am Sun 25 Nov 12

Mike Oxbig says...

A draw was a fair result. They were all over us in the first half. Another poir performance from Addison. Just what does Eddie see in him that we don't? Horrible city, horrible stadium to which I do not want to return.
A draw was a fair result. They were all over us in the first half. Another poir performance from Addison. Just what does Eddie see in him that we don't? Horrible city, horrible stadium to which I do not want to return. Mike Oxbig

8:37am Sun 25 Nov 12

RED LETTER DAY says...

THE CHICKEN LAYS A GOLDEN EGG, in the back of the Bury net . . . . . Its a great start for Brad Pittman on hs return to the fold ....................
....................
............... alright I know his name is Brett.
THE CHICKEN LAYS A GOLDEN EGG, in the back of the Bury net . . . . . Its a great start for Brad Pittman on hs return to the fold .................... .................... ............... alright I know his name is Brett. RED LETTER DAY

8:59am Sun 25 Nov 12

nonnogeppetto says...

Mike Oxbig wrote:
A draw was a fair result. They were all over us in the first half. Another poir performance from Addison. Just what does Eddie see in him that we don't? Horrible city, horrible stadium to which I do not want to return.
Poir! I suppose his performance has gone PEAR shape!!

On the serious side I do agree that he should be replaced preferably by Jason Pearce!!! That would be a miracle!!
[quote][p][bold]Mike Oxbig[/bold] wrote: A draw was a fair result. They were all over us in the first half. Another poir performance from Addison. Just what does Eddie see in him that we don't? Horrible city, horrible stadium to which I do not want to return.[/p][/quote]Poir! I suppose his performance has gone PEAR shape!! On the serious side I do agree that he should be replaced preferably by Jason Pearce!!! That would be a miracle!! nonnogeppetto

9:01am Sun 25 Nov 12

nonnogeppetto says...

Before anyone corrects me I know that French for pear is POIRE
Before anyone corrects me I know that French for pear is POIRE nonnogeppetto

9:20am Sun 25 Nov 12

big_afcb_fan says...

Lol who is this brad pitman???? I know Brett pitman scored for us yesterday ;)

All aboard the coaches to Cumbria!
Lol who is this brad pitman???? I know Brett pitman scored for us yesterday ;) All aboard the coaches to Cumbria! big_afcb_fan

10:28am Sun 25 Nov 12

tccherries says...

Buy the Bury No. 7. Best player on the pitch by a country mile yesterday. Made one, scored one. Gave Daniels the runaround. Draw was a fair result given the first half performance. Gave ourselves too much to do but we got our reward for keeping going to the end.
Buy the Bury No. 7. Best player on the pitch by a country mile yesterday. Made one, scored one. Gave Daniels the runaround. Draw was a fair result given the first half performance. Gave ourselves too much to do but we got our reward for keeping going to the end. tccherries

12:15pm Sun 25 Nov 12

RED LETTER DAY says...

big_afcb_fan........
. BRAD PITT is a film star who is making a blockbuster movie at Lulworth Cove this weekend. . . . . . . but he is no goal poacher.
big_afcb_fan........ . BRAD PITT is a film star who is making a blockbuster movie at Lulworth Cove this weekend. . . . . . . but he is no goal poacher. RED LETTER DAY

2:38pm Sun 25 Nov 12

sussexcherry says...

RED LETTER DAY wrote:
big_afcb_fan........

. BRAD PITT is a film star who is making a blockbuster movie at Lulworth Cove this weekend. . . . . . . but he is no goal poacher.
To be fair he has scored inside a few boxes in his time, instead of dribbling and shooting wide!!! (sorry, couldn't resist that!)
[quote][p][bold]RED LETTER DAY[/bold] wrote: big_afcb_fan........ . BRAD PITT is a film star who is making a blockbuster movie at Lulworth Cove this weekend. . . . . . . but he is no goal poacher.[/p][/quote]To be fair he has scored inside a few boxes in his time, instead of dribbling and shooting wide!!! (sorry, couldn't resist that!) sussexcherry

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree