Letter: 'Residents are entitled to question new artwork'

Lean Into The Wind Sculpture
Lean Into The Wind Sculpture
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The reaction to BCP Council’s new Lean Into the Wind sculpture on West Cliff has been difficult to miss.

For many residents, it has prompted less admiration than disbelief particularly after it emerged that the project cost £54,000.

 BCP cabinet member Councillor Andy Martin was reported as saying that, because the sculpture was funded through a UK Government grant, there was “no cost to local taxpayers”.

That is an extraordinary way to describe public money. The £54,000 may not have come directly from BCP’s council tax revenue but government grants are funded by taxpayers, including taxpayers living locally. Passing money through Whitehall does not make it free.

 The sculpture forms part of BCP’s £19.9 million Coastal Communities Seafront Infrastructure Programme.

The successful bid was developed under the previous Conservative led council and included practical investment in Bournemouth Pier, public toilets, beach huts, promenade infrastructure, coastal protection and lifeguard facilities. It also included an original allocation of £569,833 for a Coastal Heritage Trail incorporating public art.

Send the Daily Echo a letter for publication by emailing letters@bournemouthecho.co.uk

 However, the original bid did not specify Lean Into the Wind, its scale, its design, its creator or its £54,000 price.

Those details came later. In July 2024, BCP advertised a contract for two particular commissions, a Jekyll and Hyde themed sculpture at Alum Chine and a ‘large illusion style sculpture’ for West Cliff.

The joint contract was subsequently awarded to Circling the Square Ltd for £74,000. BCP has now confirmed that the West Cliff project alone cost £54,000.

 The funding was ring fenced for this programme, so it could not simply have been transferred into adult social care or the council’s everyday operating budget but ring fencing does not remove the responsibility to exercise judgement. The grant did not dictate this design, determine its price or prove that it represented the best possible use of the public art allocation.

 This is not an argument against art. Thoughtful public art can commemorate local history, strengthen identity and enhance shared spaces.

The Jon Egging memorial demonstrates how meaningful artwork can become a valued part of Bournemouth. With Arts University Bournemouth on our doorstep and talented artists throughout the conurbation, there were many possible ways to celebrate our coastline and involve local creativity. Art is subjective and should provoke discussion.

However, saying that people simply have different tastes avoids the central question, does this £54,000 structure represent sound judgement and value for public money?

 Our coastline is already Bournemouth’s greatest work of art. Residents are entitled to question whether this was really the most sensible way to improve it.

Jo Keeling

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos