Letter: First past the post voting system is bad for everyone

A letter writer says the first past the post system breeds a nasty them-and-us politics
A letter writer says the first past the post system breeds a nasty them-and-us politics
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

GRAHAM Boorer demonstrated (Letters 22 May) that the First-Past-The-Post voting system gives distorted results when there are multiple candidates vying for a seat. But his letter also suggested that BCP council is responsible for the continued use of this outdated voting system.

This is not the case. The voting system is defined by law and the law is made up in Westminster.

For too long the two big national parties have defended the FTFP system. And why not? It has served them well. Even in a defeat, most of their seats were safe under the FPTP system. And anyway, they would soon regain control of government when the other lot had taken their turn making a right-royal horlicks of governing.

As part of the coalition back in 2011, the Liberal Democrats forced a PR referendum from their Conservative coalition partners. The PR method brought forward was Alternate Vote for which Labour had previously shown support. Even so, the Tories campaigned very strongly against it while Labour seemed more interested in putting the boot in the coalition than in electoral reform.

A decade later, in 2022 when the political landscape was looking bleak for Labour, the Labour conference voted for electoral reform as a 'manifesto commitment.' But their leadership just ignored it.

Today, given the prospect of unprecedented defeat at the next General Election, both main parties may suddenly decide the FPTP system should at last be binned. Indeed, Andy Burnham who is angling to become Prime Minister said in a BBC interview (21 May) “I do think there needs to be reform to the electoral system to enable less point-scoring, more problem-solving – that’s what I think we need.”

Perhaps the message is getting through.

The FPTP system breeds a nasty them-and-us politics that is bad for everyone.

Dr Martin Rodger

Bloxworth Road,

Parkstone

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos