THE council has been accused of “marking its own homework” for the way in which a FuturePlaces investigation is to be carried out.
A slim majority of councillors voted for an internal audit to look into the controversial, now defunct council regeneration company.
Emails sent by councillors and officers involved may also be retrieved from the back of a request to the council’s IT department, too.
Speaking at March’s audit and governance committee, deputy Cllr Eleanor Connolly said she doesn't want to "send good money after bad to tell us what we already know".
Read more: FuturePlaces probe would come with 'significant' costs
But Green councillor Sara Armstrong said issues with FuturePlaces are best addressed with an independent investigation.
“An inquiry, not an exercise in the council marking its own homework,” she told the Echo on behalf of the Green group.
Cllr Margaret Phipps, Christchurch Independent, said there is now a “move to stop any investigation on ground grounds of ‘we can’t afford it’”.
The meeting heard from senior officers that a business case would be needed to get funding from the cabinet, which Cllr Phipps said was “a lot of scaremongering”.
“This council lost millions of pounds. It could be that it lost more in the final accounts, I don’t know that’s what an investigation should be for,” she said.
“But this was council taxpayers' money lost and we need to be open and transparent and independently find out why.”
But on that suggestion, Cllr Connolly argued an internal audit would be “thorough and fair” while allowing councillors to ask the question.
She added: “We already know an awful lot went wrong - it was down to the last Conservative administration’s risky decisions. Bad councillors make bad decisions.
“But it's still useful to look into BCP's processes to try to protect taxpayer money better in the future."
Patrick Canavan, Labour group leader (Image: NQ)
Patrick Canavan, BCP Labour group leader, told the Echo: “It’s easy to ask for other people to do an investigation paid for by the taxpayer – but (councillors) didn't seem to realise they would have to work out where the funds to pay for this would come from."
Cllr Mike Cox said FuturePlaces “deteriorated into a fairly mismanaged shambles” but said the price was “heavily paid” by the Conservatives who set it up during the local elections.
He added he doesn't want to see “good money thrown after bad to continue to investigate what is already in the public arena” adding he won’t provide additional money.
The Liberal Democrat cabinet member for finance also said the “problem” with scoping an investigation is it has “become deeply political”.
Cllr Armstrong added: “On behalf of our residents, we demand full transparency—every report, every email, every dodgy deal must be exposed.
“And we need real consequences and accountability.”
Janie Berry, director of law and governance and monitoring officer at BCP Council, told us: “We want to make clear there is complete confidence in the independence of the internal audit function and the professionalism of the council team, as evidenced by their previous investigations and reports.
“Internal audit works to a very strict set of professional standards and a code of ethics, and the work is done with complete independence and objectivity.
“The team has been externally assessed as compliant with those professional standards and code of ethics.”
Committee chairman Marcus Andrews said: “The BCP monitoring officer explained clearly that going for an external inquiry would require substantial expense and there wasn’t a budget.
"Pointing out that, another service would have to see its budget cut. A clear case would need to made-out for that change of spending to the cabinet.
“The majority decision of audit and governance was to use the BCP internal audit team to investigate. They investigated successfully, & competently, the Bayside restaurant (that was also a Tory project)."
He added: “FuturePlaces is certainly not being ‘swept under the carpet’ a report will come back to the audit and governance committee as soon as possible and within six months.
"The report may recommend that further action be taken. Some speakers mentioned that a police inquiry may be needed. The MO advised there wasn’t one currently involving FuturePlaces."
FuturePlaces was set up in 2021 by BCP Council as a way of delivering more homes and jobs on sites owned by the council.
It was closed down by the current Three Towns Alliance administration last year as part of major cost-cutting measures.
A total of £5.3million was spent by BCP Council setting up and closing down FuturePlaces across the three years. And its directors and employees were also given £110,476 in bonuses during its short lifetime.
More than £80,000 was also paid to rent out offices in Exeter Park Road, Bournemouth, while free office space was available at the town hall.
Share