DEVELOPERS have won an appeal against Borough of Poole’s (BOP) refusal to back plans for a 37-bedroomed retirement complex in the Branksome Park and Chine Gardens Conservation Area.

McCarthy & Stone took the case to the Planning Inspectorate after borough planning chiefs rejected the proposals last year.

The council said one of its reasons for refusal was the scheme “fundamentally failed to preserve or enhance the character and appearance” of the conservation area “by virtue of its massing, design, siting, materials and scale.”

Other reasons cited included the plot’s proximity to Dorset Heathlands, a Site of Specific Scientific Interest (SSSI), and issues relating to affordable housing.

However, following an inquiry carried out last month, the Planning Inspectorate has backed McCarthy & Stone’s original plans.

McCarthy & Stone regional managing director Shane Paull said: “Having worked extensively to achieve an appropriate design for our development, we are delighted with the Planning Inspectorate’s decision to approve our planning application for Lindsay Road.

“The report concludes that the proposal will enhance the character and appearance of the conservation area, and also acknowledges that our development would make a significant contribution towards the identified local need for specialist accommodation.

“This will be an attractive scheme in a fantastic location and we have no doubt that our future customers will love their new homes in this attractive suburb of Poole.”

A number of neighbours contacted BOP with their comments on the plans ahead of the latest inquiry.

John Spooner, of Lindsay Road, Poole, argued the scale of the complex was “inappropriate” and “out of keeping with the pattern of development in the area.”

And Dugald Eadie, of Branksome Park and Canford Cliffs Residents’ Association said: “If permission was granted for this development it would be used as a precedent to justify numerous similar developments in other parts of the conservation area.No doubt this would include the rest of Lindsay Road.”

Meanwhile, Rosalie Cattermole wrote: “I was pleasantly surprised to learn of the proposals for the redevelopment of 1-5 Lindsay Road.

“I actually live in Lindsay Road, which is a lovely area of Poole, and I am looking to possibly purchase a retirement apartment within this area.”