Meldrum's Verdict: No blame on James... It was risk and reward

RAIN, RAIN AND MORE RAIN: Harry Arter goes for an early bath during the second half on Saturday RAIN, RAIN AND MORE RAIN: Harry Arter goes for an early bath during the second half on Saturday

PAOLO Di Canio will need another of those famed green jackets such was the scale of rainfall at Dean Court. Maybe some new shoes, too.

It’s never boring when di Canio is around and those with a clear view of his ranting, waving and gesticulating would have been royally entertained, although the sideshow is often more absorbing than the main event when it comes to the fiery Italian.

Not so here.

Both sides made a mockery of the conditions during an intriguing and stirring final 20 minutes that saw Swindon snatch a point from the jaws of defeat.

Di Canio celebrated like he had won the World Cup, leaping up and down in the flooded technical area after Andy Williams had found the net in the 85th minute. That is his way.

But the Italian knew this was a point gained. Eddie Howe’s face told a wholly different story.

Howe is aware his team can ill-afford many more draws, with this their fourth since he returned to Dean Court in October.

For every point dropped, the upper reaches of League One appear further away. Howe alluded to as much in his post-match thoughts and Cherries are now 10 points adrift of the automatic promotion places.

This result did extend Cherries’ unbeaten run to 18 matches – equalling the benchmark set by the likes of Tommy Heffernan and Tony Funnell in 1982.

It is a magnificent achievement, albeit one Howe found it hard to be enthused about. His weekend was ruined when Williams scored the equaliser.

The Cherries manager rightly refused to point the finger of blame for the goal at goalkeeper David James.

The 42-year-old charged from his penalty area to save at the feet of Chris Martin after he had miscued a free kick deep inside the Cherries half.

The ball spilled into the path of Wes Fogden and Eunan O’Kane, who both had good opportunities to clear, but Fogden gifted the ball to Williams.

Despite Steve Cook’s attempts to recover the situation on the line, Williams held his nerve and sidefooted the ball home as James dived in vain to his right. The visiting fans expressed their glee with chants of ‘One David James’.

After the game had been left in doubt at half-time due to the relentless rain, the result was always likely to be influenced by an individual mistake, or, in James’s case, a risk that failed to pay off.

But Howe was right not to single out James. Prior to the goal, he had been outstanding.

He did well to push Tommy Miller’s drive over the crossbar after just three minutes as the heavens opened.

He then smothered Martin’s effort early in the second half, before sticking out a leg late on to deny Matt Ritchie.

His opposite number, Wes Foderingham, also stood up well in the deluge.

Foderingham dived at full stretch to push Brett Pitman’s second-half strike around the post and also brilliantly kept out Lewis Grabban’s point-blank header. Both goalkeepers also came away with credit for the way they dealt with constant back passes from their defenders.

There was little Foderingham could have done about Cherries’ opener in the first half.

Having dominated early on, Howe’s men took a deserved lead thanks to a wonderful strike from Harry Arter.

The Swindon defence failed to clear the danger in the 26th minute and the ball spilled to Arter on the edge of the penalty area. He took a touch, shimmied to his left and fired |past Foderingham into the far corner.

It was the first goal conceded by Swindon for four games.

Ten minutes later, it should have been 1-1. James Collins took advantage of an error from Cook and took aim with James stranded and the goal gaping.

Somehow, though, he managed to blaze wide. Di Canio was even more incandescent than normal. The home fans took their chance to goad the Italian.

With the playing surface graduating from slick to sticky, referee Phil Gibbs extended the interval by five minutes to allow the Dean Court ground-staff to work on a worrying patch of standing water around the halfway line.

The spiking and rolling did just enough to satisfy Gibbs and it was game on.

The longer the second half wore on, the more Di Canio raged. At one stage, the Italian was square in the face of fourth official John O’Brien after a dubious corner decision from Gibbs. Cue more laughter from the Main Stand.

Howe countered his rival with gentle encouragement directed at his players who, with the clock ticking past 66 minutes, had rarely looked in any kind of danger and were creating chances.

The status quo changed, however, when James was forced to make that key reaction save from Ritchie.

And although Foderingham at the other end denied Pitman, ultimately Swindon will feel Williams’s goal five minutes from time and a point was a fair representation of their efforts.

Match facts and Echo merit marks

Cherries: James 7.5, Francis 7, Cook 7.5, Elphick 8, Daniels 7.5, McQuoid 7 (Fogden, 73), Arter 8 (Hughes, 84), O’Kane 8*, Pugh 7.5, Pitman 7 (Thomas, 74), Grabban 7.5.

Unused subs: Tubbs, McDermott, Partington, Jalal (g/k).

Booked: Thomas.

Robins: Foderingham, N Thompson, Devera, Ward, McCormack, Ritchie, Miller (Ferry, 75), Hollands, Roberts (De Vita, 65), Collins (Martin, 55), Williams.

Unused subs: Flint, Navarro, A Rooney, Bedwell (g/k).

Booked: Williams, Ward.

Attendance: 8,777 (including 1,374 |visiting supporters).

Referee: Phil Gibbs (West Midlands).

Star man - Eunan O'Kane

It would be easy simply to hand this award to Harry Arter after his wonderful first-half goal and creative impetus throughout.

But this performance proved beyond all doubt that O’Kane can do the dirty work as well as the pretty stuff.

Playing in a deeper role, O’Kane was on hand to clear the danger on several occasions as well as being the catalyst, often playing through Arter, for many of Cherries’ best attacking moves.

O’Kane has become a massive player for Eddie Howe in the past few weeks.

Comments(13)

nonnogeppetto says...
7:37pm Sun 13 Jan 13

Before this article is hijacked by non AFCB supporters (even though some of their comments were complimentary) can I say that the above is a fair reflection and good summary of the game played under appalling condition.

I have to say that I would have been extremely gutted had the last free-kick resulted in us losing the game.

As the game progressed it was clear that a mistake by either side would be very painful sadly that mistake was of our making. But at the end of the day it was an entertaining game and both team played it as best they could have done.

boyerboy says...
8:11pm Sun 13 Jan 13

I hate to raise this now, BUT come the end of the season will we be reflecting on the too longer time it took to rid ourselves of the two clowns?
Points mean pwizes as they say and our appalling start to this season has meant that we are playing catch up ....every draw is now regarded as a bitter pill for us to swallow.In EH &JT we trust, they are doing a fab job no doubt and if they can gain promotion for us, then it will be a job worthy of being given freedom of the town.

Afcblees says...
9:05pm Sun 13 Jan 13

Big games in the league coming up still reckon we need a Bartley type player to mix things up in the middle and a natural R/W,a good cup run is great but can also defere the league form but in Eddie Howe we trust.

jakeysredd says...
9:06pm Sun 13 Jan 13

Every game now is a six pointer thanks to the bad start, Walsall away next week they have won 5 out of 6 including todays 2-1 win at Preston, nothing gets easy we need to get winning again, lots of games left think its going to be tough, remember Huddersfield going on a huge unbeaten run but missed out in the play-offs, come on you reds

denisjames says...
9:22pm Sun 13 Jan 13

I now know why there was so much interest in signing Ritchie. He for me was the man of the match and congratulations to the referee for allowing the game to continue. The best two teams in the League 1 put on a great show.

Afcbpete says...
10:54pm Sun 13 Jan 13

denisjames wrote:
I now know why there was so much interest in signing Ritchie. He for me was the man of the match and congratulations to the referee for allowing the game to continue. The best two teams in the League 1 put on a great show.
REALLY!!! Ritchie spent far to much time whinging at the referee for me, we had better players than him getting on with playing.
As you say Nonno, a fair reflection on the game. At first I did think James was at fault, but having seen the replay, it was down to the weather conditions preventing several players clearing what should of been an easy clearance. There were some dreadful decisions by the officials, it seems to be part of the Swindle way to bully them into submission, so thankfully they never got a late winner. I firmly believe on another day without a deluge we'd of proved we're a much better team and would of won and won handsomely. I certainly won't fear them should we play each other in the Play Off's, as recent draws will I think prove too costly now. But the run continues, and what a fantastic achievement that is, everyone at the club should be rightly very proud... UTCIAD

Slem_1990 says...
10:57pm Sun 13 Jan 13

No need for Bartley... get Reo-Coker on a free!! http://www.ipswichst
ar.co.uk/sport/nigel
_reo_coker_will_not_
be_staying_at_ipswic
h_town_1_1790679

Football banning order yob says...
7:31am Mon 14 Jan 13

denisjames wrote:
I now know why there was so much interest in signing Ritchie. He for me was the man of the match and congratulations to the referee for allowing the game to continue. The best two teams in the League 1 put on a great show.
Thought he was awful.. Always moaning, a dirty player.

abc100 says...
7:47am Mon 14 Jan 13

denisjames wrote:
I now know why there was so much interest in signing Ritchie. He for me was the man of the match and congratulations to the referee for allowing the game to continue. The best two teams in the League 1 put on a great show.
Don't think he had his best game but saw enough to know he must be a quality player, it was always going to be tough for him with Daniels & Pugh constantly running at him

Piston_Broke says...
8:36am Mon 14 Jan 13

Piston_Broke says...
11:38am Mon 19 Nov 12

RED LETTER DAY wrote:
..Who is next up to face the Eddie Howe STEAM ROLLER ?. . . . . Its Stevenage tomorrow night............. Be There!
If we can get past Stevenage tomorrow, and I think we will, we could witness AFCB on one of the longest unbeaten runs we'll ever see from the Cherries. On paper, our fixture list looks pretty straightforward until February, which will be an "interesting" month. Keep it up, one and all. UTC!

Without blowing my own trumpet too loudly, I saw it coming!!!

bobsworthforever says...
9:50am Mon 14 Jan 13

Football banning order yob wrote:
denisjames wrote:
I now know why there was so much interest in signing Ritchie. He for me was the man of the match and congratulations to the referee for allowing the game to continue. The best two teams in the League 1 put on a great show.
Thought he was awful.. Always moaning, a dirty player.
Totally agree glad we didnt sign Richie thought he was awful but on another day perhaps hed do better. As for David James isnt he the main reason we havent been conceeding many goals lately need to sign back up keeper urgent.

Wilkie says...
4:11pm Mon 14 Jan 13

Like Denis, knowing that Ritchie was on our radar, I kept half an eye on him during the match. Despite the conditions he showed enough ability, technique and committment for me to see why we would have been and still should be interested. I understand that he is not their outstanding player this year and therefore his valuation may be slipping back to a more sensible level. With Swindon in financial trouble, there could be an opportunity to recruit him in the summer if Swindon don't go up.

Strawbs_78 says...
7:41pm Mon 14 Jan 13

James has been superb since he joined us. His save in the first five mins was world class, also his great distribution starts so many of our attacks. Can't be blamed for the goal, he made a brave decision but it back fired. We still should've cleared it. Swindon are a good side but I certainly don't fear them after Saturday. The only way I could see them scoring was if the conditions played a part, which proved to be the case! Can't wait to play Portsmouth but important games to come before then!

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree