Faith Eckersall looks at the capital punishment debate

Faith Eckersall looks at the capital punishment debate

Lorry driver Peter Sutcliffe murdered several women

Levi Bellfield killed teenager Millie Dowler

First published in Features by

THE IDEA of monsters such as Milly Dowler’s killer Levi Bellfield, Yorkshire ripper Peter Sutcliffe and the Moors murderers swinging at the end of a hangman’s rope is not unappealing to at least 70 per cent of us, according to surveys.

Ever since capital punishment was effectively abolished in 1965, there have been yearly calls for its reinstatement and the issue was debated by every parliament until 1997.

Now, it seems, we may hear it debated again, thanks to a new campaign that has taken advantage of a tweak in procedures which means that any e-petition on the government’s website which garners more than 100,000 signatures should be referred to the Commons’ cross-party Backbench Business Committee, which will decide whether it is worthy of debate.

Led by blogger Paul Staines of the Guido Fawkes website, pro-debaters received a fillip yesterday when the leader of the House of Commons, Sir George Young MP, commented: “What else is Parliament for? People have strong opinions and it does not serve democracy well if we ignore them or pretend that their views do not exist.”

Even those vehemently against capital punishment usually acknowledge the emotions felt by those who have suffered from the crimes committed by people such as the serial killer Dr Harold Shipman or Roy Whiting, who raped and murdered Sarah Payne.

However, as Amnesty International’s head of policy and government affairs Jeremy Croft observes: “In our experience public support for capital punishment falls dramatically when people are confronted with the grim reality of what it means to put a person on trial and then kill them.”

And the reality is grim indeed.

Author Richard Clark, who has written extensively on the subject, describes the ‘long-drop’ method of hanging used in Britain’s jails. It was, he says, ‘designed to break the prisoner’s neck by allowing them to fall a pre-determined distance and then be brought up with a sharp jerk by the rope.’

None of this, however, describes adequately the horrors that have been witnessed in the gallows chambers at British prisons.

The execution of Edith Thompson in 1923 saw the condemned woman in such a state of collapse that she had to be helped on to the platform. Executioner John Ellis was so traumatised that he quit his post and later committed suicide.

Another female execution, that of Martha Brown, in public outside Dorchester Prison in 1856 had such a profound effect on the 16-year-old Thomas Hardy that he was inspired to write Tess of the D’Urbervilles.

More modern methods of execution are little better. In Alabama in 1983, according to the Death Penalty Information Centre, the electrocution of prisoner John Evans resulted in sparks and flames erupting from the electrode attached to his leg and the electrode then burst from the strap and caught fire.

And lethal injection, beloved method of dispatch in many US States, doesn’t always go swimmingly, either – in Oklahoma in 1992 Robyn Lee Parks suffered a violent reaction to the death drugs.

The vital question, of course, is how interested are we in all this?

MP for North Poole and Mid Dorset Annette Brooke says: “I still get people coming to surgeries asking me to press for the reinstatement of capital punishment. I sympathise with a lot of what they feel but have to tell them that it’s something I would never vote for. I can remember leading a sixth form debate about this subject and by the time I had researched it I was very, very strongly convinced that it was not right for the state to take people’s lives.”

However, she is glad there may be another debate.

“It’s an issue that many people hold firm views on and I’m glad the coalition made the necessary changes so that issues people feel so strongly about can be debated by MPs.”

Even then, it may not resolve much. The Bournemouth Echo sent a reporter into the town centre yesterday, to gauge public opinion.

But after an hour we could find no one with a strong view either way.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:16pm Fri 5 Aug 11

jontee says...

He must have selected people very carefully then. Did you check his views before you sent him out ?
.
I'll give you a strong view ! Bring it back now ! The low life you mention have effectively resigned from the human race and should be despatched.
.
Unfortunately, it's like the EC. There is a huge majority in the populist view but the politicians, the do gooders, and abominations like the European Court of Human Rights all have their own agenda.
He must have selected people very carefully then. Did you check his views before you sent him out ? . I'll give you a strong view ! Bring it back now ! The low life you mention have effectively resigned from the human race and should be despatched. . Unfortunately, it's like the EC. There is a huge majority in the populist view but the politicians, the do gooders, and abominations like the European Court of Human Rights all have their own agenda. jontee
  • Score: 0

12:18pm Fri 5 Aug 11

H2o-hara says...

Perhaps a Firing Squad for the likes of Braeivic in Norway would signify a form of justice ! It makes me sick to think of the millions spent on the so called " Security " for these people for " their " safety !
Perhaps a Firing Squad for the likes of Braeivic in Norway would signify a form of justice ! It makes me sick to think of the millions spent on the so called " Security " for these people for " their " safety ! H2o-hara
  • Score: 0

12:48pm Fri 5 Aug 11

Fiona Muscliffe Throop says...

Capital punishment will never be brought back.

If someone started a dont bring back capital punishment they would get many more signatures.

Not to be rude but most of the people wanting a return to hanging are the type of people who read the Daily Star.
Capital punishment will never be brought back. If someone started a dont bring back capital punishment they would get many more signatures. Not to be rude but most of the people wanting a return to hanging are the type of people who read the Daily Star. Fiona Muscliffe Throop
  • Score: 0

1:07pm Fri 5 Aug 11

mikey2gorgeous says...

Since 1970 in the US there have been 138 people sentenced to death but later found to have been wrongfully convicted.
Let's also not forget the tragic case of Derek Bentley.
Since 1970 in the US there have been 138 people sentenced to death but later found to have been wrongfully convicted. Let's also not forget the tragic case of Derek Bentley. mikey2gorgeous
  • Score: 0

2:53pm Fri 5 Aug 11

jontee says...

Fiona Muscliffe Throop wrote:
Capital punishment will never be brought back. If someone started a dont bring back capital punishment they would get many more signatures. Not to be rude but most of the people wanting a return to hanging are the type of people who read the Daily Star.
Only one way to find out. Have a referendum.
.
As for the Daily Star, perhaps you can explain why reading a particular paper makes anyone's view more or less important ?
[quote][p][bold]Fiona Muscliffe Throop[/bold] wrote: Capital punishment will never be brought back. If someone started a dont bring back capital punishment they would get many more signatures. Not to be rude but most of the people wanting a return to hanging are the type of people who read the Daily Star.[/p][/quote]Only one way to find out. Have a referendum. . As for the Daily Star, perhaps you can explain why reading a particular paper makes anyone's view more or less important ? jontee
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree