New Forest RSS Feed


New Forest

£79,878 for ‘unfairly sacked’ New Forest town clerk


A SACKED town clerk has been awarded nearly £80,000 of taxpayers’ money after a tribunal found his employers had unfairly dismissed him.

Andrew Rimmer was fired by Lymington and Pennington Town Council last October after several periods of sick leave following a heart attack.

But a tribunal ruled that the dismissal was unfair and ordered the authority to stump up for his past and future lost earnings.

The 51-year-old also made a late bid to be reinstated as the £37,800-a-year town clerk as the tribunal neared its conclusion at Dukes Keep in Southampton yesterday.

But a panel ruled out the scenario, agreeing that in the interests of continuity at the authority, the current “locum” town clerk should remain in his role.

Employment judge Rohan Pirani added: “There may be broad issues with trust [if Mr Rimmer were to be reinstated], though no specific criticism was made of the claimant in this manner.

“It is a very small council and the position of town clerk is a very important and sensitive role. The council is happy with the present incumbent.”

Earlier, the tribunal was told how Mr Rimmer had been suffering from depression and anxiety that was so severe he could not even face opening letters from his bosses to discuss his absenteeism.

The tribunal had heard that his medication had left Mr Rimmer with a stammer and he could not face speaking on the phone.

His partner Jill Ellaway, the tribunal heard, was acting as a go-between with the council.

He claimed that no-one attempted to contact him during his periods of illness and eventually he was dismissed following the formation of a sub-committee at the council.

Council chiefs claimed that services had started to suffer in his absence, including employees being overpaid and the council’s annual budget not being prepared.

In total the council was told it would have to pay £79,878, which included £14,978 in pay he had lost out on since being dismissed and £55,636 to compensate for future loss of earnings.

Afterwards Mr Rimmer, of Fennel Gardens, Lymington, told the Daily Echo: “I feel vindicated. I don’t feel pleased because it is an unfortunate outcome. But I feel vindicated in many ways.”

A council spokesman said a decision on whether to appeal against the ruling would be made after the next full town council meeting.

More New Forest News



Your Say YourEcho

bournemouthmike, Bournemouth says...
8:03pm Wed 1 Jul 09

i'm going on the sick if you get lotto type payouts!

To be fair the article says "several" periods of sickness but doesn't say how many/how long and over what period and what his previous sickness record was. I'm sure the tribunal took this into account, and I'm sure the payout will cure the depression!

thesyrup1, Bournemouth says...
9:12pm Wed 1 Jul 09

I've no doubt at all they will appeal. Afterall, it's not their money that will be paying solicitors is it? They will drag it out for quite a few months yet. Hope if they appeal, and lose, the next Judge increases the award. Be nice if it could be made to come out of their pockets, that will concentrate their minds a bit.

butlincat, bournemouth says...
7:08am Thu 2 Jul 09

Was he providing sick notes? If so the council employees who issued the dismiassal should be slung out for not knowing basic law - they cant do their jobs properly and are a burden which has cost the taxpayer £80,000 - i cant see a tribunal giving him £80,000 unless things were in order - council employees DO YOUR JOBS!! - YOURE PAID WELL ENOUGH!! paid very well too for silly jobs and get loads of paid holidays and take ages to do anything!!

In Absentia, Bournemouth says...
9:31am Thu 2 Jul 09

It looks pretty clear that he was the victim of petty local politics. The blame ultimately lies with the local elected councillors.

If the Council had been following it's sickness procedures properly then the award would'nt have been made. Yet another small local council wasting money that could be put to better use.

MoordownMarc, Bournemouth says...
1:58pm Thu 2 Jul 09

All employers will tell you that it is virtually impossible to sack employees nowadays.
Employment tribunals who tend to favour the employee can cost employers thousands of pounds in legal fees even if they win as costs are very rarely awarded in their direction.
In this case of course the good people of Lymington and Pennington pick up the tab. They could sack those in Council who made the mistakes and then face the whole expensive process again. Mad!

Comments are closed on this article.

ANDREW Rimmer ANDREW Rimmer

Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »