News RSS Feed


the social media rolling gif

Get social with the Echo - click to find out how and where!


Winning picture disqualified from Wildlife Photographer of the year contest and pulled from Moors Valley exhibition


CONTROVERSY has dogged the Wildlife Photographer of the Year contest and just two days before the competition exhibition was due to be unveiled at Moors Valley Country Park near Ringwood, the winning entry has been disqualified.

The picture, entitled the Storybook Wolf, by Spanish photographer Jose Luis Rodriguez, prompted a long-running debate as to whether it featured a wild wolf as the photographer claimed or a trained animal.

The photographer denies the wolf is a model wolf.

The competition organisers, however, effectively ended the argument on Wednesday by disqualifying the photograph, which will not now be included in the Moors Valley exhibition, which runs until February 28.

The judges have also decided there will not now be an overall winner.

In a statement, Louise Emerson, from the Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition office, said: “It saddens us to confirm that after a careful and thorough investigation into the image the Storybook Wolf, the co-owners of the Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition, the Natural History Museum and BBC Wildlife Magazine, have disqualified the winning entry of the photographer José Luis Rodríguez.

“The judging panel was reconvened and concluded that it was likely that the wolf featured in the image was an animal model that can be hired for photographic purposes and, as a result, that the image had been entered in breach of Rule 10 of the competition.”

The photographer, however, strongly denies that the wolf is a model.

• Because the disqualification was only announced on Wednesday, after Saturday's Daily Echo Magazine went to press, the photograph appears in a feature about the exhibition.

The article includes more stunning images which were entered in the competition, including the Highly Commended Terns in a Dive Queue by Winchester photographer Paul Sansome plus more details about the exhibition at Moors Valley.

See a selection of our favourite pictures from the Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition here



Your Say YourEcho

MJD, HAMWORTHY says...
1:27pm Sat 23 Jan 10

Well if that the case, i will not be taking the family there for the day out planed.

Henry Bear, Ferndown says...
6:07pm Sat 23 Jan 10

Why ??

A man possibly cheats and one photo is removed.

But you feel the need to ruin your familys day out at a great location which has so much more than one photo.???

How strange, you must be a great parent

MJD, HAMWORTHY says...
8:06pm Sat 23 Jan 10

Henry Bear wrote:
Why ?? A man possibly cheats and one photo is removed. But you feel the need to ruin your familys day out at a great location which has so much more than one photo.??? How strange, you must be a great parent
Did not spoil the family day out as we have been to Moors valley more times than i can remember. Only going to see the photos as i am in to wild life photography. My prize winning photo of two wild barn owls sat on a five bar gate would have been disqualified, ho they are tame ones. Further more no one has proved he has cheated yet. Had a very good day at monkey world.

MartiB, Blandford Forum says...
9:05pm Sat 23 Jan 10

MJD wrote:
Henry Bear wrote:
Why ?? A man possibly cheats and one photo is removed. But you feel the need to ruin your familys day out at a great location which has so much more than one photo.??? How strange, you must be a great parent
Did not spoil the family day out as we have been to Moors valley more times than i can remember. Only going to see the photos as i am in to wild life photography. My prize winning photo of two wild barn owls sat on a five bar gate would have been disqualified, ho they are tame ones. Further more no one has proved he has cheated yet. Had a very good day at monkey world.
Well if you were into Wildlife Photography then you would have been following this story since it was revealed and the evidence that has been published on the internet since before Christmas is quite compelling.
I for one will be going to see the exhibition as there are a lot of quality images by 'Real' Wildlife Photographers, who spend a lot of time, effort and skill to obtain their shots, rather than those who take images of tame animals and pass them off as something they are not.

oversixty, Bournemouth says...
9:49pm Sat 23 Jan 10

Meanwhile have a look here for some superb wildlife photographs from Dorset -
http://www.flickr.co
m/groups/dorsetwildl
ife/

In Absentia, Bournemouth says...
4:48pm Sun 24 Jan 10

The photograph was still on display yesterday lunchtime when I visited the exhibition and postcards of it were still available for sale.

I have to say, that even taken with a captive animal it is a stunning picture and would have been widely published even if the photographer had been honest about it's origins and how it was taken. He's been very foolish.

There are some stunning images there on display, especially the winner of the black and white category. I'd recommend the exhibition to everyone.

Comments are closed on this article.

ROW: The disqualified image the Storybook Wolf ROW: The disqualified image the Storybook Wolf

Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »