When news happens text pix and video to 80360. Start your message with BE then leave a space.
Don't miss our new Youth Sport supplement every Thursday inside your Echo
All of today's content from across the site, all in one place at bournemouthecho.co.uk/today
7:00am Thursday 30th April 2009 in
A CONTROVERSIAL euthanasia campaigner dubbed Dr Death will hold suicide workshops at a hotel in Bournemouth next week.
Dr Philip Nitschke has defended plans for the sessions at Hamilton Hall in Boscombe, a venue used by gay naturists, claiming: “It is often people who have experienced social repression who can best understand and identify with our cause.”
The move has been condemned by Roman Catholic leaders in Bournemouth.
But Hamilton Hall boss John Bellamy pledged to go ahead with Dr Death’s lessons in euthanasia the public meetings and workshops on Tuesday and added: “Trouble is, we have had too many centuries of religious claptrap.”
Read Ed Perkins' opinion about Dr Death's workshops
See the Related Links at the bottom of this story
Australian activist Dr Nitschke attempted to hold workshops in Bournemouth last year but was forced to abandon his plans after venues cancelled his bookings when they realised what the workshops were about. He gives advice on what he considers to be the best ways to commit suicide.
But this year Mr Bellamy has pledged to allow the meetings to continue, even if they are opposed by members of the public.
“There needs to be a reshaping of people’s education and beliefs around such a subject” he said. “It seems we demand humans to live with indignity, pain and anguish whereas we are kinder to our pets when their suffering becomes too much – it simply is not logical or mature.”
Speaking from Darwin, Australia, Dr Nitschke said: “It seems those opposing the right of elderly Britons to access end-of-life information went out of their way to close the meetings down in 2008.
“This time we have been very pleased to have the support of Mr Bellamy, who has made it clear they will not bow to pressure by those who want to censor the meetings.”
Father Anthony Pennicott, of the Sacred Heart Church in Richmond Hill, opposed the workshops and said: “From the Christian point of view we believe that human life is created by God and that an individual’s life therefore belongs to God.”
He voiced fears that vulnerable people could be at risk if euthanasia was legalised. “Allowing voluntary euthanasia is likely to place vulnerable people in danger of being manipulated and pressurised by people who think they know best or who have ulterior motives to end their life.”
Hamilton Hall, Carysfort Road, Boscombe, advertises itself as “a retreat for the 21st century, exclusively for gay and bisexual men” and a “clothing optional” venue.
The meetings and workshops are due to be held between 10am and 1pm on Tuesday. Similar events are also planned for venues in Brighton, Stroud and Glasgow.
Comments(27)
K9F
says...
8:42am Thu 30 Apr 09
2Much...again!
says...
9:07am Thu 30 Apr 09
K9F wrote:"Dr Philip Nitschke deserves at the very least the opportunity to deliver his presentation to those that may be interested in what he has to say"
What on earth has gay naturists got to do with the subject matter? From a personal perspective and for what it is worth my mother sadly passed away January this year from pancreatic cancer. Once informed that the cancer was too advanced for treatment my mother was in fact under ‘sentence of death.’ Despite the hospital doing everything it could to ‘make her comfortable,’ physically and psychologically for my mother it tore her apart. Several times she expressed a strong desire to ‘go,’ and in her own words “As God has decided to take me I pray every morning that he takes me quickly! If I could end it myself I would!” Four weeks later she passed away. My mother was also a Catholic! Dr Philip Nitschke deserves at the very least the opportunity to deliver his presentation to those that may be interested in what he has to say.
ry8000
says...
9:48am Thu 30 Apr 09
Zzzz
says...
10:04am Thu 30 Apr 09
ry8000
says...
10:35am Thu 30 Apr 09
Zzzz wrote:So we should all be censored? This information is freely available on the internet, so banning a meeting will do nothing to stop a determined person from obtaining this knowledge.
I understand that Dr Nitschke wants to help terminally ill people to die with dignity, but I'm concerned that the euthanasia method he espouses could be used by suicidally depressed people, or even those seeking to murder others (if it is undetectable, as he claims).
Emulated
says...
10:38am Thu 30 Apr 09
vik
says...
11:04am Thu 30 Apr 09
ry8000
says...
11:12am Thu 30 Apr 09
vik wrote:Couldn't agree more.
For those of you who don't agree the answer to this is simple - don't go to the workshop!!! Having watched memebers of my family suffer agonising and expensive treatment and not pull through i think that euthanasia should be an individual's own choice.
Laurie Marsh
says...
12:17pm Thu 30 Apr 09
AndyBournemouth
says...
12:24pm Thu 30 Apr 09
sarlane
says...
12:47pm Thu 30 Apr 09
Laurie Marsh
says...
12:56pm Thu 30 Apr 09
sarlane wrote:That name has been around for years.
Just who has dubbed this man "Doctor Death"? Is it the Echo being sensationalist again? As others have said, what this man is advocating is freely available on the internet and if you don;t like what he says, don't go to the workshop. Simple.
djd
says...
1:01pm Thu 30 Apr 09
silky
says...
2:21pm Thu 30 Apr 09
Emulated
says...
3:57pm Thu 30 Apr 09
silky wrote:Can't think of a better place to hold such a workshop. All those attending will have a gay time.
Crumbs I just looked at the Hamilton Hall website! *blushes*
WIGGINSv
says...
5:26pm Thu 30 Apr 09
PokesdownMark
says...
5:27pm Thu 30 Apr 09
dopey
says...
5:28pm Thu 30 Apr 09
Emulated
says...
7:49pm Thu 30 Apr 09
dopey wrote:I think those deciding in ending their life would find making such decisions rather difficult.
For those who choose this path to end their suffering, could there be some way of helping others with organ donation? (remembering some organs may be damaged by the choice of euthanasia method)
Vikki27
says...
10:07pm Thu 30 Apr 09
EGHH
says...
6:24am Fri 1 May 09
AndyBournemouth
says...
7:54am Fri 1 May 09
Zzzz
says...
9:51am Fri 1 May 09
ry8000 wrote:If the information is freely available on the internet, why does Dr Nitschke need to give such talks at all? There's something creepy about the way he travels around the world actively promoting methods of suicide.
Zzzz wrote:So we should all be censored? This information is freely available on the internet, so banning a meeting will do nothing to stop a determined person from obtaining this knowledge.
I understand that Dr Nitschke wants to help terminally ill people to die with dignity, but I'm concerned that the euthanasia method he espouses could be used by suicidally depressed people, or even those seeking to murder others (if it is undetectable, as he claims).
Please, let's not lose more of our freedoms!
AMAZEDGUY
says...
11:11am Fri 1 May 09
2Much...again!
says...
4:48pm Fri 1 May 09
Vikki27 wrote:My point exactly...well put!
Omg I just looked at the Hamilton Hall webpage!! Hahaha!!!!! More power to them I say!
As for the subject in hand...I agree whole-heartedly with euthanasai. Given the choice between a long and painful death or dying with dignity, I'd like to think I'd go for the latter.
However, I'm *VERY* concerned that these workshops will be providing those suffering from severe depression what are essentially 'tips' on the best ways to end their lives.
For people with depression, there is ALWAYS hope for recovery, even if they don't see it. Euthanasia should only be sought as an option for those with terminal illnesses.
poolebabe
says...
5:51pm Mon 4 May 09
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Search for jobs with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Find the right person for you with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Search for homes with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
Search for cars with the Daily Echo
Search Now »
2Much...again! says...
8:19am Thu 30 Apr 09
Secondly, if someone is ill, and living with pain for example, I believe it's every person's right to choose whether they end this sooner rather than later..I know I would, so it should be a one on one meeting, not a "workshop".
Thirdly, this man could also hold workshops on how to pull people out of such desperation instead of giving false hope, as this country is very unlikely to change the laws on euthanasia.
The article also mentions suicide..and he says himself: "It is often people who have experienced social repression who can best understand and identify with our cause"...these people need support to live with discrimination, not chit chats on how to end it all.
What a load of rubbish..and ECHO..anyone dies as a result of these seminars, I would say well done for publishing times and places. You fell right into his hands!
Security word: rise-again