News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Outrage as Dorset doctor earns £157 an hour


HEALTH chiefs in Dorset have defended their decision to pay agency doctors £157.50 an hour to treat prisoners.

They say that two incidents last year where prisoners were treated by agency medics were ‘urgent’ – requiring staff with specialist skills and knowledge.

Figures on hourly rates for agency workers were obtained by the Conservative Party under the Freedom of Information Act.

All NHS organisations were asked about the highest amount they paid to an agency worker in each month from May to October 2008.

“What we need is more full time doctors and nurses, who can get to know patients properly, rather than temporary agency staff on mega-salaries.”

The Taxpayers’ Alliance

Top of the pay-list was a Dorset prison doctor who earned £157.50 an hour in May 2008, funded by Dorset Primary Care Trust (PCT).

This was the equivalent of an annual salary of £307,125, the Tories said.

The organisation also paid £105 an hour for the services of a prison GP between June and October 2008 – which would be an annual salary of £204,750.

South Western Ambulance Service NHS Trust was found to have paid £25.78 an hour in July 2008 for the services of a telecommunications analyst, the equivalent of a £50,271 yearly wage.

The ambulance service also hired a management accountant at £23.01 an hour in June (annual salary of £44,869.50) and GP car drivers at £22.98 an hour in May 2008 (annual salary of £44,811).

The highest rate paid in the country was £187.50 an hour for an anaesthetics medical consultant used by Whipps Cross University Hospitals NHS Trust in London.

But Dorset health bosses said agency staff were only used when ‘absolutely necessary’.

A PCT spokeswoman said: “In prison healthcare, there are occasions when urgent medical cover is required at very short notice in order to continue to provide the very important healthcare services to patients in prison in Dorset.

“Agency staff that are able to provide this medical cover are required to have specialist skills, knowledge and experience of the healthcare system and therefore are able to command a higher rate for their services.”

She added that NHS Dorset was continuing to negotiate with agencies for better rates.

The agency fees are thought to be rates paid to private firms, not to the Government’s non-profit agency NHS Professionals.

Campaign group The Taxpayers’ Alliance branded the wages ‘mega-salaries’.

A spokesman said: “Agencies have creamed off millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money, whilst patients continue to receive below par care.

“What we need is more full time doctors and nurses, who can get to know patients properly, rather than temporary agency staff on mega-salaries.”


Comments(10)

nonnogeppetto says...
8:19am Mon 5 Jan 09

Someone who is alive as a result of treatment by an agency Dr is highly unlikely to be quibbling over how much it cost. As for prisoners, the ones who either defended them in court or put them in prison, (you know who I mean!!) cost a great deal more than £150 an hour, maybe we should be up in arms about that cost to the tax payer. It is a known fact that agency cover of any sort is the most expensive hourly rate!

gerbil112 says...
9:36am Mon 5 Jan 09

"The ambulance service also hired... ...and GP car drivers at £22.98 an hour in May 2008 (annual salary of £44,811)".

And the regular GP Drivers for the Out of Hours Service are paid a basic salary of between £12,517 and £13,617 (NHS Pay Band 1), plus Unsocial Hours payments of up to 25%. Not far off minimum wage!

MICHAELJCARPENTER2003@YAHOO.CO.UK says...
11:27am Mon 5 Jan 09

ITS NOT THE DOCTOR WHO GETS PAID THIS SUM BUT THE AGENCY. IN MOST CASES THE DOCTOR WOULD BE LUCKY TO GET ONE THIRD OF THIS SUM AS THE AGENCY CHARGES FOR COSTS TO COVER THEIR STAFFS WAGES AS WELL AS FOR THE DOCTORS. ALSO WHEN THE DOCTOR IS NOT WORKING HE DOES NOT GET PAID BY THE AGENCY INBETWEEN THE JOBS THAT THEY FIND FOR HIM.

In Absentia says...
12:30pm Mon 5 Jan 09

Outrage? What Outrage?

I'd want to be paid a high hourly rate for treating prisoners.

If these people needed a decent lawyer, they'd probably pay more per hour for their services.

silky says...
4:07pm Mon 5 Jan 09

Spin! You can prove anything with figures.

PokesdownMark says...
5:05pm Mon 5 Jan 09

Nothing in this increasingly typical daily wail style Echo story alarms me.
The headline figure and that of the £105 figure are for highly skilled specialists working in challenging circumstances. The other salaries mentioned, around 45-50k, are pretty ordinary too for staff with particular technical skills.
Once again.... move along please, nothing to see here.

poolebabe says...
5:56pm Mon 5 Jan 09

PokesdownMark wrote:
Nothing in this increasingly typical daily wail style Echo story alarms me.
The headline figure and that of the £105 figure are for highly skilled specialists working in challenging circumstances. The other salaries mentioned, around 45-50k, are pretty ordinary too for staff with particular technical skills.
Once again.... move along please, nothing to see here.
I agree with you! A non story. Is the Echo suggesting prisoners do not deserve to be treated if they are ill? Human rights won't allow for that! I wonder what the alternative is? Medical treatment from the prison wardens? If that's the going rate charged by an agency, what are the prisons supposed to do about it? We could all debate about how morally wrong it is, but it's a pretty pointless argument really! The debate should be about preventing crime in the first place!

Happymother says...
7:22pm Mon 5 Jan 09

Why cant money be better spent like having a doctor available to talk to at night/weekends instead of waiting 5 hours to be rung back. Prisoners get priority when I cant even get my doctor to visit my poorly son at 3am at night. What do we pay taxes for.

sam-broadstone says...
8:17pm Mon 5 Jan 09

Pay the doctors what they like, just get them working. I'd rather be treated by a qualified doctor than a foreign, dubiously qualified, just graduated one working for peanuts. And if I have to pay for it so be it.
Prison costs are more of a concern.

rook says...
8:29pm Mon 5 Jan 09

I don't have a problem with any doctor getting £150 per hour - they're one of the few professions who deserve it.

As mentioned, £40-60K for skilled workers is pretty normal as far as I'm aware i.e. accountants, IT analysts, business consultants etc.

Also, if this is actually the agency fee, the doctor could be getting less than 70% of this. I know £100 per hour is still very nice, but they train at Uni for years (although apparently medics sometimes drink the occasional beer), then work very hard to earn their money.

Whatever 'disgust' we're supposed to feel about what is paid to doctors, soccer stars, TV personalities or bankers is irrelevant if the only crime is taking what is available in a free market.


Most popular






Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses