Twin Sails bridge shortlisted for architectural award

Twin Sails bridge shortlisted for architectural award Twin Sails bridge shortlisted for architectural award

BEWILDERED residents have criticised the shortlisting of Poole’s £21.6million Twin Sails Bridge for an architectural award, because of the string of closures that have marred its first year.

Civic leaders met today’s announcement that Poole Harbour’s second crossing has been shortlisted for the coveted Royal Institute of British Architects 2013 South West Award with delight. However, some residents who spoke to the Daily Echo questioned the timing of the nomination.

All our Twin Sails pictures Fred Winwood, chairman of Hamside Residents Association, said: “Architects are notorious for designing things that don’t work. A bridge that is called a Twin Sales Bridge and when it blows a gale of wind has problems because the sails cannot cope with the wind force. How on earth they can recommend that for an architectural award is beyond me.”

Mary Stamper, of Baiter, Poole, said: “I think it is a marvellous bridge but because of all the problems I don’t think an award is fitting. I really don’t think it should be up for an award right now.”

Poole resident John Sprackling said: “Frankly I would have preferred something more functional. The only time it’s visible is when it’s erect, which is a few times a day. I definitely don’t think it deserves an award.”

Meanwhile, Craig Williams of Poole agreed there may be a few raised eyebrows about it being in the running for an architectural accolade.

He told the Echo: “Fair enough, it’s a pretty impressive structure when it’s in the upright position, but how can it be up for an award when it’s had so many initial problems.”

The Twin Sails Bridge, which opened amid a wave of community pride in March 2012 is on the shortlist with 18 other projects from across south west England.

Opposition includes the Bryanston School Boathouse, Blandford; the Big Shed assembly workshop, Beaminster; and Taunton’s Castle Green Bridge.

The History of the Twin Sails project Borough of Poole leader Elaine Atkinson said: “I am thrilled that the Twin Sails Bridge has been recognised amongst such an impressive field showcasing excellence in architectural design.

“This demonstrates how the Twin Sails Bridge is helping to raise Poole’s profile on the international stage.”

It hasn’t always been plain sailing for Poole’s contemporary road bridge. The structure, spanning the Back Water Channel, was dogged by a number of technical problems during its first months of operation.

Work carried out since its grand opening includes replacement of the valves which control all four barriers and road surface repairs.

During its first months of operation, over a six week period from April 9, there were 15 occasions when it was closed to traffic.

All our Twin Sails stories A Royal Institute of British Architects spokesman said: “RIBA South West Awards recognise good, innovative architecture within the region. Shortlisted projects will now be assessed by a regional jury with the winners announced on June 12 at an awards ceremony at STEAM, Swindon.”

Regional winners can then be considered for a RIBA National Award.

Comments(12)

Old Colonial says...
9:25am Fri 22 Mar 13

"Civic leaders met today’s announcement that Poole Harbour’s second crossing has been shortlisted for the coveted Royal Institute of British Architects 2013 South West Award with delight."

And that just about sums up the whole fiasco. This bridge was built for prestige NOT function. Watch for all the happy self-satisfied smiling faces of the 'civic leaders' if it does win.

Frank28 says...
10:17am Fri 22 Mar 13

It won't be winning any awards for reliability!

Teddy 1 says...
10:27am Fri 22 Mar 13

How much will the council spend on attending the award ceremony I wonder?!

speedy231278 says...
11:30am Fri 22 Mar 13

"A bridge that is called a Twin Sales Bridge"...

...is an example yet again of poor editorial standards!

LornaBournemouth says...
11:36am Fri 22 Mar 13

I see Fred WinGEwood is having his usual daily moan...

Congrats to all concerned ,and now that all the teething problems are out of the way we now have a bridge that Poole can be proud of!

Letcommonsenseprevail says...
11:50am Fri 22 Mar 13

A bridge too farce.

live-and-let-live says...
12:11pm Fri 22 Mar 13

its a very innocuous bridge when the sails are down. and its not so wonderful when they're up.

Baywolf says...
12:11pm Fri 22 Mar 13

You see it's design not practicality that's cost 13 million and how can it be awarded anything other than a councillors wet dream for prestige when it dosnt work..

muscliffman says...
12:32pm Fri 22 Mar 13

Why the surprise, this Bridge always was a vanity project. Actually working was secondary to the Councillors who believed the look of it was far more important. But at least there is another awards 'jolly' on the way for them.....Cheers!

Ebb Tide says...
2:03pm Fri 22 Mar 13

The structural engineering is brilliant (two beams rather than four cantilevers) but the co-ordinated package (including surfacing the structure) and its procurement aspects something else altogether. It may be the structural engineering deserves an award but the 'treatment of the structure' and the overall 'project management', notwithstanding the help given by the Client, less so.

jobsworthwatch says...
3:44pm Fri 22 Mar 13

....'shortlisted for architectural award'. Its has to be I suppose because Poole councillors were 'taken in' by this vanity project.
But, I can't imaging this 'troubled bridge over water' ever wining a 'best (functional) bridge' award!

Glashen says...
9:06am Sat 23 Mar 13

Ebb Tide wrote:
The structural engineering is brilliant (two beams rather than four cantilevers) but the co-ordinated package (including surfacing the structure) and its procurement aspects something else altogether. It may be the structural engineering deserves an award but the 'treatment of the structure' and the overall 'project management', notwithstanding the help given by the Client, less so.
I agree again we have seen a project damaged by poor management of detail. Sadly it is often the case that the vision dominates to such an extent that the job of making it happen gets forgotten. In the case of the Twin sails Bridge everything was going well until it came to actually making the bridge work in operation when a number of actually quite minor teething problems spoiled the project. Sadly if the bridge now gets this award it will be tarnished but hopefully the bridge's teething issues are now behind it.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree