Hospital apology as HIV patients asked "how did you catch it?"

Hospital apology as HIV patients asked "how did you catch it?" Hospital apology as HIV patients asked "how did you catch it?"

HOSPITAL boss Tony Spotswood has apologised to a Bournemouth charity after its service users complained about being asked “unnecessary and intrusive” questions during treatment.

Body Positive said HIV positive patients were left angry and hurt after being asked how they contracted the virus during treatment at the Royal Bournemouth Hospital, despite the question being “entirely unnecessary”.

Chief executive Mr Spotswood has said sorry and assured Body Positive manager Richard Erven that such questioning will stop.

Now Mr Erven is urging him to ensure his apology makes a difference.

“While I accept that he is sincere in both his apology and in giving his assurance we must wait and see what actually transpires,” said Mr Erven.

He said a similar assurance year ago made no difference.

Mr Erven said he understands that transmission routes need to be known but the issue is dealt with when an individual is diagnosed.

“This information remains on the medical record. To ask someone who has been HIV positive for a number of years how they became HIV positive is both intrusive and unnecessary.”

Bournemouth has twice the national average of people living with HIV with the biggest growth in numbers among young heterosexuals between 16 and 24.

Mr Erven said Body Positive was “determined to put an end to all forms of discrimination against people who are HIV positive” and stressed that most transmissions in the area are as a result of straight sex and less than two per cent attributed to injecting drug users.

A spokeswoman for the Royal Bournemouth Hospital confirmed Mr Spotswood had apologised but declined to comment further.

We welcome your comments on this story but please read our new house rules before you post.

Comments(6)

guisselle says...
1:53pm Wed 23 Jan 13

How sad that so many young people
are being diagnosed, transparency
must be allowed if we are to address
this awful disease. i think there should
be more support and advice from
schools and religious organisations.

manyogie says...
5:46pm Wed 23 Jan 13

I,ve been pos for 17 yrs now, anyone can ask me what they like, but it's my choice IF they NEED to know.

WannabePM says...
7:38pm Wed 23 Jan 13

Surely knowing how people catch these things is a good idea? Can anyone tell me why not?

Golf girl says...
10:15pm Wed 23 Jan 13

No-one needs to know how someone got infected, not even healthcare professionals as the mode of transmission does not affect healthcare decisions. It is an intrusive and irrelevant question.

sarcher says...
4:53pm Thu 24 Jan 13

A flu jab can make someone test HIV positive, There is NO GOLD STANDARD in HIV testing.

fluarix "flu vaccine"
"False positive ELISA serologic tests for HIV-1, Hepatitis C, and especially HTLV-1 may occur following influenza vaccination. These transient false-positive results may be due to cross-reactive IgM elicited by the vaccine. For this reason, a definitive diagnosis of HIV-1, Hepatitis C, or HTLV-1 infection requires a positive result from a virus-specific confirmatory test (e.g,Western Blot or immunoblot)."

sarcher says...
9:30am Fri 25 Jan 13

check out omsj.org and its hiv innocence group to see how crappy these tests are/

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree